The democratic deficit of the european union

To give an example, up to Septemberout of the 86 pieces of legislation adopted in that year the Government of the United Kingdom had voted in favour of the legislation 84 times, abstained from voting twice and never voted against.

Of course national parliaments have all agreed to pool sovereignty in the EU institutions, but they are entitled to do that and have done so with their eyes wide open. Transparency and accountability The EU does fall down on transparency.

And all the EU member states are represented in the Council of Ministers. Prosperity, peace and cooperation rely on the idea of democracy. We should respect and support that governance in order to optimise the Union.

However, these negative assessments of the democratic character of the EU have been challenged by scholars who point out that a parliamentary model of European democracy is not a suitable benchmark for assessing democracy at the EU level, because it is, like federalist states, a nonmajoritarian institution.

The Maastricht Treaty introduced the status of EU citizenship, granting EU citizens the right to vote and stand in elections to the European Parliament and municipal elections in their country of residence, irrespective of their nationality subject to age and residency qualifications.

We should not give up claiming rights, but we should also respect our obligations. So I propose to discuss the presence or absence in the EU of these characteristics. Although the Council of Ministers now holds public sessionsthe elected governments of the member states are not keen to grant access to debates in the Council, which are held behind closed doors — and where most important decisions are made.

On the other hand, unfortunately, there are doubts about democracy in European Union, as many citizens claim that there is a democratic deficit. But does that make it democratic or does it have, as some argue, a democratic deficit?

Although any democratic system may potentially suffer from a democratic deficit, the concept is most often used in the context of supranational institutions, the European Union EU in particular. The turnout in European elections has also been declining every election without exception to a low of Majorities have to be built afresh for each item of legislation by explanation, persuasion and negotiation.

We should not ignore the fact that the longest period of peace and harmony in the European continent is identified with the existence of European Community and the EU, and undoubtedly democracy plays an important role in it.

He argued that the European Parliament then the Assembly suffered from a democratic deficit as it was not directly elected by the citizens of the Community. Council of the European Union[ edit ] Voting in the Council of relevant Ministers is usually by qualified majority votingand sometimes unanimity is required.

Individual members of the incoming Commission are nominated by national governments and the proposed Commission is or is not approved jointly and severally by the Council of the European Union and the European Parliament. The parliament is transparent enough and I have always found Commission civil servants to be much more open to enquiries than those working in the British government.

Citizens can lobby their own MEPs, or all MEPs if they wish — and it is often individual complaints from citizens that lead to groundbreaking legal judgments by the European Court of Justice.

Democracy and democratic deficit in the European Union

Not even representatives of the European Parliament can attend. These debates can be viewed [24] in real time on the Internet. The fear is that a "semi-elected" Commission president might be "too partisan to retain the trust of national leaders; too powerless to win the loyalty of citizens".

The treaties of Amsterdam and Nice, which amend the Treaty of Maastricht that founded EU, failed to alter the European structure significantly. The verdict Clearly the EU structure has defects when assessed by the normal standards of Western democracy — but I would argue that the British parliament, with its unelected House of Lords and an unrepresentative House of Commons in terms of the balance of political parties to votes castis even less democratic.

They concluded that "this does not suggest that the majority of German voters are treating the contest as a chance to choose a Commission President.

Eurosceptics have for a long time questioned the legitimacy of the EU — but that charge is difficult to sustain. It could and should be their job to call their own government ministers to account for what they do in Brussels, but most national parliaments do a very poor job in this regard — the House of Commons being one of these poor performers.

The European Parliament is made up of MEPs from all 28 EU member states, each elected using various forms of proportional representation unlike the House of Commons, which is elected through a widely criticised first-past-the-post system.The club remains vulnerable to the charges of operating with a “democratic deficit” that alienates many voters.

Start with what is still the central institution, the European Commission. Although any democratic system may potentially suffer from a democratic deficit, the concept is most often used in the context of supranational institutions, the European Union (EU) in particular.

The most popular criticism of the EU’s levels of democracy refers to the dispossession of national institutions that is not sufficiently.

Democratic deficit

A ‘Democratic Deficit’ in the European Union? par Mihail Milev∗ Doctorant à l’Université de Sofia, Bulgarie.

The Democratic Deficit in the European Union

Abstract: This article defines and conceptualises the academic debate about the term 'democratic deficit'. It examines further where and how the term can be applied to the EU institutional system and what its impact is on the system.

The European Union has an inextricable link to democracy, the system that is to ensure the accomplishment of the Union’s aims. It is significant to mention the existence of ‘democratic deficit’, a situation that damages the Union and its institutions. The european union has regularly been accused of suffering from a democratic deficit.

If liberty and equality, as is thought by some, are chiefly to be found. European Council and its Presidency, for example – consolidate decade-long In Defence of the ‘Democratic Deficit’: Reassessing Legitimacy in the European Union*.

The democratic deficit of the european union
Rated 5/5 based on 49 review